Know Your Olive Oil

What should you actually look for?

Olive oils can differ in how they're made, how they taste and how they behave in the kitchen.

Terms like extra virgin, origin and variety can tell you something, but they don't tell you everything.

Here are a few things worth understanding.

What should you look for?

Type

Extra virgin, virgin and refined olive oils are produced differently and can have different characteristics and uses.

How It's Made

How the olives are processed and the oil is extracted affects the final oil. Terms such as cold extraction can provide useful information, but should be understood alongside the rest of the product.

Variety

Different olive varieties can produce oils with different aromas, flavours and levels of bitterness or pepperiness.

Origin

Where the olives come from can tell you something about the oil, but origin alone does not determine quality or whether an oil is right for a particular use.

Flavour

Olive oil can be mild, fruity, grassy, bitter, peppery or more robust. These differences can matter when the oil is a noticeable part of the dish.

Freshness & Storage

Olive oil changes with time, light, heat and air. How it is packaged and stored matters after production too.

Start with how you're using it.

The oil you want for one job isn't necessarily the oil you want for another.

Everyday Cooking

When olive oil is part of the cooking process and you want something versatile and practical.

Dressings

When the flavour of the oil becomes part of the dressing and the finished dish.

Finishing

When the oil is added at the end and its flavour is much more noticeable.

Dipping

When the oil itself is one of the main things you're tasting.

Olive oil doesn't all taste the same.

Stronger doesn't automatically mean better, and milder doesn't automatically mean worse. Different flavours suit different people and different dishes.

Mild

Softer flavour that interferes less with other ingredients.

Fruity / Fresh

More noticeable aromas and fresh olive or plant characteristics.

Bitter

Bitterness can be a natural characteristic of some olive oils and is not automatically a defect.

Peppery

Some oils create a peppery sensation, particularly at the back of the throat. This can also be a normal characteristic.

Does single origin mean better?

Not necessarily.

A single origin or single variety oil can give you more information about where an oil comes from or the characteristics of a particular olive.

A blend can be deliberately created to achieve a particular flavour, balance or consistency.

Neither description alone tells you which oil is better for you.

What matters is what is in the bottle, how it was produced and whether its characteristics suit how you want to use it.

Try it for yourself.

You don't need to be an olive oil expert. Taste it and pay attention to a few simple things.

How strong is the flavour?
Is it mild or does it stand out?

What do you notice?
Fruity, grassy, bitter, peppery or something else?

Does it work with the food?
Try the same oil in cooking, in a dressing or simply with bread.

Do you actually like it?
Personal preference matters too.

There isn't one “best” olive oil.

A mild oil might make sense for everyday cooking, while a more distinctive oil might be exactly what you want over a finished dish.

Single variety, blended, mild or robust can all have their place.

The point is to understand what you're getting and whether it works for how you want to use it.

Ready to choose?

Explore the olive oils available at Foodways.